Reminder Emails: Pros and Cons

July 22nd, 2010 by Anthony Schneider

Don’t Forget to Phone Your Aunt

Everyone likes a helpful reminder. We’re grateful when someone reminds us that it’s our sister’s birthday, or our favorite store is having a sale. But we’re not as keen on our mother’s imprecations to dress more warmly or phone Aunt Agatha. It’s the same with email: some reminders are useful and welcome, while others fall on deaf (aka unsubscribe-prone) ears.

We’ve found that good reminders yield high render and click rates and very few unsubscribes, while poorly honed reminder emails don’t connect and sometimes result in a slew of unsubscribes.

Your Email Pal: When Do Reminder Emails Succeed?

Reminder emails work when they are meaningful, timely, relevant and, above all, wanted. For example, when we like a brand or promotion, we’re happy to receive a reminder that a sale is ending. For B2B communications, that’s similar to a conference registration, or call for speakers.

The first step is writing a meaningful subject line so that your audience knows they are being reminded—and being informed of something relevant. The content and messaging is also important. For the most part, reminder emails work best when they are short, sweet and to the point.

The Email That Cried Wolf: When Do Reminder Emails Fail?

Reminder emails are less effective when they are blunter instruments, ill-timed, too frequent, or not relevant to or wanted by the receiver. No one wants multiple reminders about the same thing. Similarly, we get bored by re-cycled content or emails that are badly targeted.

For B2C marketers, it’s important to remember that sale and promotion extensions and frequent reminders may serve only to deafen your audience, or sound like you’re nagging them, or undermine your real, targeted messaging. The same is true in the B2B space, where multiple reminders simply sound like nagging or a desperate effort to get you to do something.

Reminder Rules

Keep subject lines and copy meaningful, make sure the content is relevant to the audience, and keep the email short and to the point. Let your recipients know that they are receiving a one-time reminder, or if they are in a series, be up front about that. You have to let the customer know that you’re not mindlessly re-sending the same copy to the same list.

Segmentation works. It’s important to make your email segmentation transparent.  Email Transmit recently sent a reminder email for NBC Universal that went only to recipients who had not clicked on a special promotion. eHarmony incorporates segmentation in subject lines, which state simply, “You haven’t read our emails lately.”

Permission Reminders

Some of the most welcome reminder emails are ones we ask for. Witness Amazon’s birthday list (receive an email a week before it’s your mum’s birthday), or Zappos “Notify Me” brand notices, which let you know when a particular product and size combination becomes available.

. . .

Savvy marketers know that relevance is more important than frequency, and quality trumps quantity. Reminder emails are no exception. Done right, they can work for you, but a poor reminder email sends the wrong message and sends subscribers running for the digital hills.

Tags: , , , , , ,

  • Kathy

    Not fond of email reminders at all….I already wake up to close to a hundred emails each morning. Professional people need to develop skills to take care of their own schedules-with our calendars in hardcopy or technology…we are all set.

    http://www.kathycondons.blogspot.com

  • Anthony S

    Thanks for your feedback. That's interesting — there's not one email reminder that you have found valuable or worthwhile?

  • Anthony S

    The perils of writing marketing articles: In researching the excellent Zappos reminder email service, I had to find a pair of shoes I liked but they didn't stock. Which I did. Then, I decided I just had to have them, so 15 minutes and $100 later, I ordered myself a pair of running shoes.

  • Eric

    I've signed up for a number of regular email reminders. I think they're great. When they're not, I unsubscribe/opt out. Which brings to mind one thing you might discuss, Mr. Schneider: when emailers make it a huge pain in the ass to unsubscribe or ignore unsubscribe requests. Nothing can hurt your brand like disrespecting the customer like that, IMO.

    http://www.cantaloupecontent.com

  • AnthonyWS

    Good point, Eric. Making it difficult or impossible to unsubscribe is a shoddy email practice at best, an unethical violation of email standards at worst. Needless to say, it's easy to unsubscribe from Email Transmit emails.